On February 12, 2025, Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) and Representative Joe Wilson (R-SC) reintroduced the National Right-to-Work Act in the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives, respectively. This legislation seeks to eliminate provisions in federal law that allow employers to require union membership or payment of union dues as a condition of employment. By repealing these provisions, the bill aims to ensure that union participation and financial support are voluntary for all workers nationwide.
At first glance, the proposal may seem like a step toward worker freedom, but in reality, it is an orchestrated effort to weaken unions, drive down wages, and strip states of their right to set their own labor laws. This bill is not only an attack on the ability of workers to collectively bargain for better pay and benefits, but it is also a blatant overreach of federal power that contradicts the very principle of state sovereignty that many of its proponents claim to support.
Right-to-Work Laws Lead to Lower Wages and Benefits
Numerous studies have shown that workers in right-to-work (RTW) states generally experience lower wages, fewer benefits, and weaker workplace protections compared to those in states where unions have stronger bargaining power.
According to the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), workers in right-to-work states earn about 3% lower wages on average than those in non-RTW states, even after adjusting for cost of living, industry, and demographic factors.
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) has found that states with RTW laws tend to have lower median household incomes.
Workers in RTW states are less likely to have employer-sponsored health insurance or retirement benefits. The National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) found that unionized workplaces in non-RTW states have higher rates of employer-provided healthcare and pensions.
RTW laws increase workplace fatalities. Studies, including one published in the American Journal of Public Health, show that RTW states have higher workplace fatality rates due to weaker union advocacy for safety standards.
When unions are weakened, all workers—union and non-union—lose out. Without collective bargaining power, wages stagnate, benefits shrink, and workplace protections erode, creating a race to the bottom where corporations, not workers, reap the benefits.
A Direct Attack on State Sovereignty
Beyond harming workers, the National Right-to-Work Act also undermines state sovereignty by imposing a federal mandate that overrides individual states’ labor laws.
Currently, each state has the right to decide whether to adopt right-to-work laws or allow unions to require dues from all represented workers. The National Right-to-Work Act would strip states of this right, forcing all states to comply with RTW policies, even if they have chosen otherwise.
Many Republicans and right-wing groups who push this legislation frequently argue for “state rights” in other policy areas, such as gun laws, abortion laws, and environmental regulations. However, when it comes to undermining unions and lowering labor costs for corporations, they abandon this principle, exposing the hypocrisy of their stance.
States like California, New York, Washington, and Illinois have deliberately chosen pro-union policies through their legislatures and voter-backed initiatives. By imposing a nationwide RTW law, Congress would override the will of these voters and their democratically elected representatives.
A Federal Power Grab Disguised as Worker Freedom
The real beneficiaries of the National Right-to-Work Act are not workers, but corporations and anti-union lobbying groups like the National Right to Work Committee.
If right-to-work laws truly benefited workers, states would adopt them on their own, without federal intervention. Instead, this bill seeks to impose RTW policies on all states, whether they want them or not.
This is a classic example of government overreach, but instead of helping workers, it’s designed to favor big business by crushing collective bargaining power.
By weakening unions, corporations gain more leverage over their workforce, reducing the need to provide competitive wages, benefits, and safe working conditions.
Constitutional Concerns and the Tenth Amendment
The Tenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution reserves powers not delegated to the federal government to the states and the people. By mandating a national right-to-work policy, Congress would be infringing upon the autonomy of states to regulate their own labor markets.
Ironically, many of the same lawmakers who champion “limited government” are pushing a top-down federal law that strips states of their ability to decide their own labor policies. This contradiction highlights that the National Right-to-Work Act is less about worker freedom and more about weakening the labor movement at a national scale.
Conclusion: A Smokescreen for Corporate Control
The National Right-to-Work Act is not about protecting workers—it is about empowering corporations at the expense of workers’ wages, benefits, and safety. The evidence is clear: right-to-work laws lead to lower wages, fewer benefits, and weaker workplace protections. This legislation is also a direct attack on state sovereignty, imposing a federal mandate that overrides the will of voters in states that have chosen to support unions.
If proponents of right-to-work laws truly believed in worker freedom, they would let states make their own decisions instead of forcing a national policy. Instead, this bill represents a federal power grab, stripping states of their rights and tilting the balance of power further in favor of big business.
Rather than dismantling unions, policymakers should be strengthening worker protections, ensuring fair wages, and promoting policies that empower—not weaken—America’s workforce.
.
We need your help. While Geddry is a volunteer effort there are still costs to providing pro-democracy content to Coos County. Your donation will help cover printing costs, web hosting fees, and of course we need to raise money for our noncommercial community radio station to cover the costs of equipment.
Please make your tax deductible donation here because we can’t do this alone.